Todd Haynes is a talented director known for his films that tackle taboo topics, explore identity dilemmas, and challenge societal norms. His unique storytelling style and thought-provoking narratives have captivated audiences and critics alike. But which of Haynes’s movies are considered the best? Which films have left a lasting impact on cinema and pushed the boundaries of filmmaking? In this article, we will rank the top Todd Haynes movies based on critical acclaim and audience reception.
From his masterpiece “Far From Heaven” to his groundbreaking debut “Poison,” Haynes’s filmography is filled with remarkable works that delve into complex themes, showcase powerful performances, and push the boundaries of cinematic storytelling. Join us as we delve into Haynes’s filmography and explore the films that have solidified his reputation as one of the most innovative directors of our time.

Key Takeaways:
- Todd Haynes is a talented director known for his films that tackle taboo topics, explore identity dilemmas, and challenge societal norms.
- His films are ranked based on critical acclaim and audience reception.
- “Far From Heaven,” “Carol,” and “Safe” are considered some of his best works.
- “I’m Not There,” “Velvet Goldmine,” and “Dark Waters” showcase Haynes’s versatility as a director.
- “Wonderstruck,” “Poison,” and “The Velvet Underground” explore unique narratives and push cinematic boundaries.
1. Far From Heaven (2002)
“Far From Heaven” is considered Todd Haynes’s masterpiece. This critically acclaimed drama set in the 1950s follows the story of a perfect housewife, played by Julianne Moore, whose life is shattered when she discovers her husband’s hidden homosexuality. The film delves into themes of social taboos, racism, and the facade of suburban perfection. It received widespread acclaim for its stunning visuals, powerful performances, and thought-provoking exploration of societal norms.
Julianne Moore delivers a remarkable performance that earned her an Academy Award nomination for Best Actress. Dennis Quaid also shines as the conflicted husband, providing a nuanced portrayal of a man struggling with his identity.
“Far From Heaven is a transcendent tribute to the melodramas of the 1950s, seamlessly blending intricate storytelling with exquisite aesthetics.” – The New York Times
With its captivating storytelling, breathtaking visuals, and profound themes, “Far From Heaven” solidified Todd Haynes’s position as one of the greatest filmmakers of his generation. It is a must-watch for fans of Julianne Moore and those interested in thought-provoking cinema.
| Critics’ Reviews | Awards |
|---|---|
| “A sumptuous and evocative masterpiece that expertly explores themes of love, identity, and societal expectations.” | Academy Awards: 4 nominations |
| “Haynes creates a visually stunning world that transports the audience back to the 1950s while challenging societal norms and prejudices.” | Golden Globe Awards: 4 nominations |
| “Moore’s performance is a tour de force, capturing the inner turmoil of her character with grace and vulnerability.” | Independent Spirit Awards: 5 nominations, 3 wins |
Don’t miss out on experiencing the brilliance of “Far From Heaven” – a cinematic gem that continues to captivate audiences and provoke meaningful discussions to this day.
2. Carol (2015)
“Carol” is a mesmerizing romantic drama directed by Todd Haynes. Adapted from Patricia Highsmith’s novel “The Price of Salt,” the film takes place in 1950s New York and delves into the poignant and forbidden love affair between an aspiring photographer named Therese Belivet, played by Rooney Mara, and an elegant socialite named Carol Aird, portrayed by Cate Blanchett.
The narrative explores the complexities of same-sex love and the societal prejudices that permeated the era. As Therese and Carol navigate their relationship amid the prevailing homophobic attitudes, they also confront their own personal struggles for happiness and self-acceptance.
“Carol is a beautiful love story that transcends the boundaries of time and societal norms. Todd Haynes masterfully captures the intensity and longing between the two lead characters, skillfully juxtaposing their desires against the backdrop of a repressive and judgmental society.”
– Cinema Review Magazine
The film garnered widespread critical acclaim for its exquisite cinematography, meticulously recreated period detail, and exceptional performances by Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara. Blanchett’s portrayal of Carol earned her an Academy Award nomination for Best Actress, and Mara received a nomination for Best Supporting Actress.

Key Details:
| Director | Todd Haynes |
|---|---|
| Writer | Phyllis Nagy |
| Starring | Cate Blanchett, Rooney Mara, Kyle Chandler |
| Genre | Romance, Drama |
| Release Year | 2015 |
“Carol” stands as one of Todd Haynes’s greatest achievements, showcasing his ability to craft visually stunning and emotionally captivating narratives that resonate with audiences. The film remains a testament to the enduring power of love and the inner strength required to challenge societal norms.
3. Safe (1995)
“Safe” is a psychological drama that stars Julianne Moore in a mesmerizing performance. She portrays Carol White, a suburban housewife who becomes afflicted with a mysterious illness. The film explores themes of anxiety, isolation, and the impact of modern society on individuals.
The haunting atmosphere of “Safe” grips viewers from start to finish. Todd Haynes’s storytelling is both thought-provoking and unnerving, leaving audiences on the edge of their seats. Moore’s portrayal of Carol White is compelling and showcases her incredible range as an actress.
Safe stands as one of Haynes’s most mesmerizing and thought-provoking works, delving deep into the psychological complexities of its characters.

Safe is a must-watch for fans of Todd Haynes and anyone seeking a gripping exploration of the human psyche.
| Director | Year | Genre |
|---|---|---|
| Todd Haynes | 1995 | Psychological Drama |
4. I’m Not There (2007)
“I’m Not There” is a unique biographical drama that takes audiences on a mesmerizing journey through the life and music of the legendary Bob Dylan. Instead of following a conventional narrative, director Todd Haynes opts for a bold and audacious approach by portraying different aspects of Dylan’s persona through six different actors. One of these extraordinary performances is delivered by the talented Cate Blanchett.
This visually stunning film challenges traditional biopic conventions and offers a kaleidoscopic exploration of Dylan’s artistic evolution, personal struggles, and profound impact on popular music. Haynes skillfully weaves together various narratives, soundtracks, and moods to create a cinematic experience that mirrors the complexity and enigma of Dylan himself.
Blanchett’s portrayal is particularly noteworthy, capturing the essence of Dylan’s electric, enigmatic stage persona during his mid-1960s period. Her performance earned critical acclaim and garnered numerous accolades, including an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actress.
“I’m Not There” pushes the boundaries of traditional storytelling and serves as a testament to the transformative power of art. Through Haynes’s visionary direction and the incredible performances of the ensemble cast, the film offers a profound exploration of music, identity, and the ever-shifting nature of artistic expression.
With its evocative visuals, innovative narrative structure, and mesmerizing performances, “I’m Not There” stands as a testament to Todd Haynes’s creative genius and his ability to capture the spirit of a legendary artist like Bob Dylan.

Mesmerizing Performances and Musical Brilliance
One of the film’s greatest strengths is its ability to capture the essence of Dylan’s music and his impact on popular culture. Through his iconic songs, “I’m Not There” immerses viewers in the poetic lyrics, mesmerizing melodies, and rebellious spirit that defines Dylan’s artistry.
Additionally, the film features exceptional performances from actors such as Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, and Richard Gere, each embodying different facets of Dylan’s persona. This diverse ensemble brings authenticity and depth to their respective portrayals, further enhancing the film’s rich and multi-layered narrative.
5. Velvet Goldmine (1998)
“Velvet Goldmine” is a mesmerizing musical drama directed by Todd Haynes that pays homage to the glam rock era of the 1970s. The film takes the audience on a captivating journey through the rise and fall of a fictional bisexual glam rocker, brilliantly portrayed by Jonathan Rhys Meyers.
Set in the backdrop of an extravagant and rebellious music scene, “Velvet Goldmine” delves into themes of identity, sexuality, and the lure of fame. Through dazzling visuals and a truly immersive soundtrack, the film celebrates the flamboyant and audacious spirit of glam rock.
Todd Haynes’s direction brings a vibrant energy to the screen, capturing the essence of the era with stunning aesthetics and meticulous attention to detail. The film’s engaging narrative and powerful performances, including those by Ewan McGregor, Christian Bale, and Toni Collette, make “Velvet Goldmine” a must-watch for fans of both Todd Haynes and glam rock.
Witness the glitz, the glam, and the raw emotions as the characters navigate their personal and artistic journeys amidst the decadence and excess of the music industry. Immerse yourself in the vibrant world of “Velvet Goldmine,” where passion, rebellion, and self-discovery collide.

Notable Quotes:
“Glam opens up a world of new possibilities – of self-discovery, of sexual liberation, of artistic expression.” – Todd Haynes
“Jonathan Rhys Meyers delivers a mesmerizing performance as the enigmatic and androgynous glam rocker.”
Key Themes:
- Glam rock
- Sexuality
- Identity
- Fame
Cast:
| Actor | Character |
|---|---|
| Jonathan Rhys Meyers | Brian Slade |
| Ewan McGregor | Curt Wild |
| Christian Bale | Arthur Stuart |
| Toni Collette | Mandy Slade |
6. Dark Waters (2019)
“Dark Waters” is a gripping legal thriller that delves into the haunting realities of corporate greed and its catastrophic impact on the environment. Directed by Todd Haynes, this critically acclaimed film is based on a real-life environmental lawsuit against chemical giant DuPont.

The film follows the journey of attorney Robert Bilott, played by the talented Mark Ruffalo, as he risks everything to uncover the dark secrets hidden by DuPont. Bilott’s relentless pursuit of justice not only puts his career on the line but also takes a toll on his personal life.
“Dark Waters” sheds light on the dangers of unregulated chemical pollution, highlighting the urgent need to hold corporations accountable for their actions. The film’s compelling storytelling and impactful message serve as a wake-up call, urging viewers to take action and protect our environment.
“The system is rigged. They want us to think it’ll protect us. We protect us. We do.” – Robert Bilott
Mark Ruffalo’s powerful performance as Robert Bilott garnered critical acclaim, captivating audiences with his portrayal of a man driven by integrity and a sense of moral duty.
Dark Waters Film Ranking:
| Position | Movie | Year |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Far From Heaven | 2002 |
| 2 | Carol | 2015 |
| 3 | Safe | 1995 |
| 4 | I’m Not There | 2007 |
| 5 | Velvet Goldmine | 1998 |
| 6 | Dark Waters | 2019 |
| 7 | Wonderstruck | 2017 |
| 8 | Poison | 1991 |
| 9 | The Velvet Underground | 2021 |
While “Dark Waters” ranks sixth in Todd Haynes’s filmography, it remains a standout work that showcases the director’s ability to immerse audiences in thought-provoking narratives grounded in real-world issues.
7. Wonderstruck (2017)

“Wonderstruck” is a visually stunning film that takes viewers on a mesmerizing journey through time and imagination. Directed by Todd Haynes, this film tells the parallel stories of two deaf children, set 50 years apart. Through its dual timeline narrative, “Wonderstruck” explores themes of connection, curiosity, and the power of the human spirit.
Haynes’s inventive storytelling techniques are on full display in “Wonderstruck,” captivatinly offering glimpses into the past and present while highlighting the universal experiences that unite us all. The film celebrates the resilience of its deaf characters, celebrating their unique perspectives and abilities to navigate a silent world.
With breathtaking visuals and meticulous attention to detail, “Wonderstruck” transports viewers into a world of wonder and discovery. The film’s young cast delivers heartfelt performances, further immersing audiences in their emotional journeys. “Wonderstruck” is a testament to Todd Haynes’s ability to create a truly extraordinary and awe-inspiring cinematic experience.
8. Poison (1991)
“Poison” is Todd Haynes’s debut feature film and a milestone in the New Queer Cinema movement. It consists of three separate stories that explore themes of sexuality and societal taboos. “Poison” is experimental in its storytelling techniques and visual style, establishing Haynes as an innovative director with a unique voice. The film is hailed for its boldness, social commentary, and powerful performances.

| Key Details | Best Features |
|---|---|
| Director | Todd Haynes |
| Release Year | 1991 |
| Genre | Drama |
| Themes | Sexuality, Societal Taboos, New Queer Cinema |
| Notable Performances | N/A |
| Box Office | N/A |
9. The Velvet Underground (2021)
Experience the mesmerizing journey of The Velvet Underground in this captivating documentary directed by Todd Haynes. The film meticulously chronicles the influential rock band’s rise to fame and their groundbreaking collaboration with art icon Andy Warhol. Through a stylish presentation and immersive storytelling, this documentary celebrates the band’s musical legacy, their impact on the art scene, and their lasting influence on popular culture.
Directed by Todd Haynes, known for his exceptional films, The Velvet Underground offers a unique insight into the band’s artistic evolution and cultural significance. As you watch this documentary, you’ll be transported back to the 1960s and 1970s, experiencing the vibrant energy and raw talent that characterized the band’s music. From their avant-garde experiments to their subversive lyrics, the film highlights The Velvet Underground’s audacious spirit.
Immerse yourself in the captivating world of The Velvet Underground, a documentary that not only explores the band’s history, but also delves into their collaborations with Andy Warhol and his factory, where innovative art and groundbreaking music converged. Discover how their artistic synergy shaped an era and influenced generations of musicians and artists to come.
Whether you’re a fan of The Velvet Underground, a lover of music documentaries, or simply looking for an inspiring cinematic experience, watching The Velvet Underground is a must. Through the lens of Todd Haynes, this film pays homage to a legendary band and their extraordinary contribution to the world of music and art.
FAQ
What is Todd Haynes known for?
Todd Haynes is a talented director known for his films that tackle taboo topics, explore identity dilemmas, and challenge societal norms.
Which Todd Haynes movie is considered his masterpiece?
“Far From Heaven” is considered Todd Haynes’s masterpiece, receiving widespread acclaim for its stunning visuals, powerful performances, and thought-provoking exploration of societal norms.
What is “Carol” about?
“Carol” is a romantic drama that explores the forbidden love affair between two women in 1950s New York, delving into themes of same-sex love, societal prejudice, and personal happiness.
What is the plot of “Safe”?
“Safe” is a psychological drama that follows a suburban housewife who develops a mysterious illness seemingly triggered by her environment, exploring themes of anxiety, isolation, and the impact of modern society on individuals.
How does “I’m Not There” depict Bob Dylan’s life?
“I’m Not There” is a unique biographical drama that portrays different aspects of Bob Dylan’s persona through six different actors, offering a visually stunning and audacious exploration of Dylan’s career and impact on popular music.
What is “Velvet Goldmine” about?
“Velvet Goldmine” is a musical drama that pays tribute to the glam rock era of the 1970s, following the rise and fall of a fictional bisexual glam rocker and exploring themes of identity, sexuality, and the allure of fame.
What is the premise of “Dark Waters”?
“Dark Waters” is a gripping legal thriller based on a real-life environmental lawsuit, where an attorney risks everything to uncover a chemical company’s dark secrets, shedding light on the dangers of corporate greed and the fight for justice.
What is “Wonderstruck” about?
“Wonderstruck” is a visually stunning film that tells the parallel stories of two deaf children, set 50 years apart, exploring themes of connection, curiosity, and the power of imagination.
What is “Poison” known for?
“Poison” is Todd Haynes’ debut feature film and a milestone in the New Queer Cinema movement, consisting of three separate stories that explore themes of sexuality and societal taboos with experimental storytelling techniques and powerful performances.
What is “The Velvet Underground” about?
“The Velvet Underground” is a documentary film that chronicles the influential rock band’s rise to fame and their collaboration with art icon Andy Warhol, exploring their musical legacy, impact on the art scene, and lasting influence on popular culture.
ncG1vNJzZmianKS0qLXNoGWoqpdkr6a%2F02arqJyUYrWixc2eqmaln6u2pr%2BMq5ino5WZfA%3D%3D